We Logged a Finance Influencer's Picks on October 11. Here's the 18-Day Scorecard.

31 Oct 2026 · RESEARCH NOTE
We Logged a Finance Influencer's Picks on October 11. Here's the 18-Day Scorecard.

On October 11 we fact-checked three viral stock videos and logged every checkable claim with its price at the time (data/social-claims-log.json). This is an interim check, not a final grade. The two seasonal calls have a grading date of December 31. We're publishing the midpoint anyway so nobody can say we only reported the parts that went our way.

The scorecard so far

Logged prices are from our October 11 entry, which used the last close before that weekend. The current price is our October 29 snapshot.

PickThe claimLoggedOct 29Change
VST (Vistra)"Buying on every dip"$161.48$140.95−12.7%
AMZN (Amazon)"Highest-conviction position"$262.43$243.79−7.1%
XLV (healthcare)Up by December after midterms "100% of the time"$170.81$184.04+7.7%
XLRE (real estate)Avoid: loses after midterms "100% of the time"$41.61$43.06+3.5%

For reference, SPY fell 1.1% from our first post-log snapshot (Oct 12) to Oct 29.

Lumentum (LITE), the third "buy the dip" name, wasn't price-logged on October 11 because we didn't track it yet. We added it that day. From our first snapshot on October 12 ($995.41) to October 29 ($919.53), it's down 7.6%.

Reading it fairly

  • Healthcare is working. XLV closed at a 52-week high on October 29. Our score for it is now 52 ("Extended"). The call looks right so far, but the easy part of the move may be done.
  • The real-estate "avoid" call is wrong so far. XLRE is up 3.5% while the market dipped.
  • The three single-stock "buy every dip" picks are all down 7–13%. Vistra's real catalyst, the $4.2 billion DOE nuclear loan, was already public and priced in when the video ran.

18 sessions is short, and none of this is final. But the pattern fits what we said on October 11: the confirmable facts in those videos were real, and the trading calls built on them are a separate question.

Why we keep doing this

Anyone can say they "called the bottom." We log the claim, the price and the date before we know the outcome, then publish the result either way. We've added these interim marks to the log. The final grades go up after December 31.

Live scores: VST · AMZN · XLV · XLRE · LITE.

Scores in this piece come from the ZonedInOut model. How the score works →

Frequently asked

How did the influencer's October 2026 stock picks perform?
As of Oct 29, 2026: Vistra −12.7% and Amazon −7.1% since Oct 11; Lumentum −7.6% since Oct 12. The healthcare-seasonality call (XLV) is +7.7%. The real-estate 'avoid' call (XLRE) is wrong so far at +3.5%. SPY fell 1.1% over a similar window.
Is the midterm-year healthcare trade working in 2026?
So far, yes. XLV rose from $170.81 (Oct 11 log) to $184.04 (Oct 29), a 52-week high. The claim is graded on Dec 31, and the ETF now scores 52 ('Extended') on our board.
Why does ZonedInOut track influencer stock picks?
To grade claims honestly. We log the claim, the price and the date before the outcome is known, then publish the result either way.

Get the Sunday Brief

One email a week, before the open: what the board did, which calls worked, which didn't, and what changed. Free. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.